Scandalous Times by Alex Ling;

Scandalous Times by Alex Ling;

Author:Alex Ling;
Language: eng
Format: epub
Publisher: Bloomsbury UK


The Other Big Brother


From the mid-twentieth century on, two ominously prophetic works of literature have vied for the dubious honor of having their dystopian vision become reality. On the one hand, George Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-Four forced upon us Big Brother, the Ministry of Truth, and the Thought Police, describing a world where societal “integrity” is maintained through brutal repression: a controversial “picture of the future” in the form of “a boot stamping on a human face—for ever.”2 Aldous Huxley’s Brave New World, on the other hand, in gifting us with soma, the feelies, and orgy-porgy, presented an essentially hedonistic vision of suppression through satiation: a subtler (though no less effective) method of maintaining order where society has in effect been seduced into repressing itself.

Each of these visions has cast their considerable shadows over our modern lives, such that for a long time the question was “which template would win?”3 “Hard” power or “soft”? The closed fist or the sensual caress? Big Brother’s terrifying visage, or the infantile delights of Centrifugal Bumble-Puppy? Of course, on a certain, immediate level, the answer has been both. That in their eternal pursuit of order and stasis the powers that be (i.e., our foremost state representatives) are perfectly capable of encompassing, at one and the same time, brutal oppression and total permission, is so obvious that it hardly bears mentioning. The penitentiary and the shopping mall, the detention center and Amazon: regardless of their evident experiential differences, each nonetheless ultimately represents alternate forms and degrees of imprisonment and social control.

Yet in the current climate of increasingly authoritarian rule and populist politicking, it is Orwell’s vision that appears to have finally edged out Huxley’s. This ostensible victory, fueled by an overwhelming sense of fear and mistrust on the part of the general public, is even directly reflected in terms of book sales, Nineteen Eighty-Four topping the Amazon best-seller list in early 20174—sixty-eight years after its original publication—following White House Counselor Kellyanne Conway’s claim that the Trump Administration was justified in delivering “alternative facts.”5 (Huxley’s novel reached number twenty-eight on the same list at the same time.)6 So we would seem to be witnessing precisely what Orwell’s totalitarian mouthpiece O’Brien predicted, namely, the final triumph of a world of brutal oppression—where insurrection is directly answered with torture, and where the ruling Party is prepared to use any and every means to “squeeze you empty, and then […] fill you with ourselves”7—over “the stupid hedonistic Utopias that the old reformers imagined.”8

Of course, that Nineteen Eighty-Four would eventually win out in the minds of the general public is, in itself, hardly surprising, and in fact supports our own argument concerning the structure of power and the uses of scandal—in particular, as a potent tool of misdirection or obfuscation. For compared to Huxley’s vision, Orwell’s blueprint is not only infinitely easier to recognize and even accept as a real possibility; it is, at the same time, far simpler to reject.

That Orwell’s vision is easier to accept as a potential reality



Download



Copyright Disclaimer:
This site does not store any files on its server. We only index and link to content provided by other sites. Please contact the content providers to delete copyright contents if any and email us, we'll remove relevant links or contents immediately.